I’m reading this great book about brainwashing from the 1950s with a provocative title: “The Rape of the Mind” by Dr. Joost A.M. Meerloo. The whole of the document is online but I bought the physical print version because I didn’t know better. I picked it up just because it sounded interesting and it is with its oscillation between philosophy, psychology and sociology. But I was surprised to find some passages that are pretty influential in regards to the dichotomy between metrics-based design and intuitive design:
The world of tomorrow will witness a tremendous battle between technology and psychology. It will be a fight of technology versus nature, of systematic conditioning versus creative spontaneity. The veneration of the machine implies the turning of mechanical knowledge into power, into push-button power.
The devaluation of the individual human brain, replacing it by mechanical computers, also suggests the totalitarian system for which its citizens are compelled to become more and more the servile tools. The inhuman “system” becomes the aim, a system that is the product of technocracy and dehumanization and which may result in organized brutality and the crushing of any personal morality. In a mechanical society a set of values are forcibly imprinted on the unconscious mind, the way Pavlov conditioned his dogs.
In a technocratic world every moral problem gets repressed and is displaced by a technical or statistical evaluation. The problems of sound and speedy mathematics serve to overthrow ethics.
Technology based on this concept is cold and without moral standards of living, without faith and “feeling at home” in our own world. It continually stimulates new dissatisfaction and the production of new luxury without knowing why. It stimulates greediness and laziness without emphasizing restraint and the art of living.
It’s really a remarkable work.